De quel mouvement s'agit il?
[ chronomania.net - Les archives de l'ancien forum ]
écrit par Alberto le 02. Août 2002 11:09:44:
Ci-dessous vous trouverez la conclusion d'un article écrit par un horloger en disséquant/analysant un calibre de montre. Sans tricher en allant chercher l'article en question (et en ne disant rien si vous l'avez lu), quelqu'un souhaite essayer de deviner de quelle marque il s'agit?
"So how does it compare to the competition? There are some movements that match it in terms of accuracy and reliability, but in my humble opinion, none exceed it. The Rolex 3035 and 3135 match it toe to toe. But they are a lot thicker and considerably more expensive too. The Patek Philippes, while being very pretty to look at, do not match it for accuracy and are more delicate as far as reliability is concerned. Of course they’re also slightly thinner, so that does put them at a disadvantage. The JLC 889/2 does match it for accuracy, but is also too delicate to give it any competition in the reliability department. The main reason for the latter is its very weak mainspring. The whole design, while being well thought out and superbly executed, relies too much on everything being just perfect. It is just thrown out of wack too easily, when even minor things go out of adjustment. I don’t have too much experience on the Blancpain/Piguet movements. But from the few that have crossed my bench, they don’t seem to deliver the same accuracy that the XXXXXXXXX has no trouble delivering."
Réponses:
- Re: De quel mouvement s'agit il? Cyril B 02.8.2002 12:55 (0)
- On en a parlé longuement ici si je me souviens bien j'ai lu l'article alors Mohamed 02.8.2002 11:48 (0)